What’s Hot/What’s Not: 01/29/12

It’s an all Not Hot edition this week…

What’s Not:

Suze Orman – Orman’s response to people criticizing her hawking a pre-paid debit card could have been handled a lot better.

Quid Pro Quo? – MSNBC allowed Ed Schultz to participate in a Democrat retreat as a panel guest. Schultz also got an interview with Nancy Pelosi while at the retreat. There may have been no connection between the two but it’s a situation that on its face doesn’t look good.

Rah, Rah, Rah! – CNN getting caught twice showing a staffer whipping up the crowd at its Florida debate raises all kinds of questions about the authenticity of the crowd response to the debate.

CNN to Trademark “Magic Wall” – Four years after it debuted, and after its become a common term of reference in the industry? Good luck with that…

Violent Tweeting? – A tweet was shown on the lower thirds of The Ed Show which called for the Secret Service to break the finger of Jan Brewer and “drop her”. Is this the kind of progressive talk MSNBC wants to espouse? One would hope not…

The Ed Show Incites Violence?

NewsBusters’ Jack Coleman writes about The Ed Show posting a questionable tweet on its crawl…

Here’s a tweet that appeared while Schultz was talking with Dionne –

Next time Jan Brewer sticks her finger in President’s face, the Secret Service should break it & drop her. #edshow #p2

The tweet came from a Twitter user named “chaplinlives” who resides in Massachusetts — or as we happy few conservatives with domiciles here call it, the People’s Republic of Taxachusetts. Consider yourself warned — “chaplinlives” uses a photo of a lion for a Twitter avatar (No, not the one in “The Wizard of Oz”), so he or she is not to be trifled with.

MSNBC should not have run that tweet. There have to be some standards in what is allowable from viewer commentary. This one crosses a line that The Ed Show shouldn’t have crossed.

The Hazards of Live TV: #25,142

If Obama’s numbers were that low I think we’d be hearing a lot more about it…

What’s Hot/What’s Not: Submissions…

Post your nominations for this week’s What’s Hot/What’s Not. I’ll post the finalists on Sunday night…

CNN Wants to Trademark WHAT?!?!?

TVNewser’s Alex Weprin reports that CNN is looking to trademark the term “Magic Wall”. I hope they fail. Spectacularly.

Now, however, it appears that the channel wants to make sure that the “Magic Wall” is for CNN use only. Earlier this month the channel applied for a trademark on the term “Magic Wall” with the U.S. Patent and Trademark Office, according to filings obtained by TVNewser.

If CNN was really serious about trademarking Magic Wall they would have done so four years ago when they first rolled it out. Doing it now is just silly and probably opens the network up to all sorts of generic use arguments. I hope all the other networks fight them over it and CNN winds up losing.

I’m no lawyer but it seems to me that should CNN win this it would establish a bad precedent where a network introduces a concept and a name, it takes hold across the industry and is used all over, and then years after the fact the network tries to regain control of it by applying for a trademark; in effect trying to put the genie back into the bottle it itself opened.

Out here in the tech world we don’t wait around four years to apply for a trademark on an idea we came up with. We apply for it before we even announce the product or concept.

CNN Florida GOP Debate Ratings…

CNN is noting its ratings from the GOP Debate in Florida last night but also of note is the network is breaking out social media stats in a big way which is a break from past debate releases…

CNN’S GOP FLORIDA DEBATE WAS #1 LAST NIGHT; POSTS BEST CNN DELIVERY YET IN THE KEY DEMO 25-54

DRAWS 5.4 MILLION TOTAL VIEWERS AND 1.7 MILLION IN KEY DEMO 25-54

ALSO DRAWS AN ADDITIONAL 1.2 MILLION TOTAL VIEWERS AND 562K IN THE DEMO DURING WEST COAST PRIMETIME

ANDERSON COOPER 360 TOPS THE COMPETITION AT 10P

CNN.com page views & video highest of last five CNN debates

According to Nielsen Fast National data, CNN’s Florida debate (8-10p, ET), moderated by Wolf Blitzer delivered 5.4 million total viewers and 1.7 million in the key target demographic 25-54 last night, Thursday, January 26. This represents CNN’s best debate yet this election cycle in the key demo and second best among total viewers (behind the Las Vegas GOP debate on 10/18). Last night’s debate ranked fourth among all primary debates so far this cycle in the key demo (including broadcast) and second among cable-only debates (behind only FNC’s 12/15 debate).

CNN was, by far, top rated during the 8-10p, ET time period last night among the cable news networks in both total viewers and the key demo. CNN topped FNC among total viewers by 160% (5.4m vs. 2.1m) and MSNBC by 444% (5.4m vs. 985k). In the target demo CNN topped FNC by 330% (1.7m vs. 405k) and MSNBC by 702% (1.7m vs. 217k).

O’Reilly Looks at MSNBC’s Pat Buchanan Fiasco…

(via J$)

It was kind of a missed opportunity. Sandy Rios doesn’t help herself any by bringing out the “1st Amendment” shield in her first breath. Sorry Sandy, the First Amendment primarily covers government intrusion, not what a private enterprise allows. And the Progressive crank didn’t fare much better. O’Reilly actually came out looking rather sane and smart by comparison, despite his silly assertion that everyone at MSNBC is progressive extreme. And it’s too bad that the segment veered quickly from what MSNBC did with Buchanan to whether Buchanan was correct or not.

Inside CNN’s iReport

Poynter’s Craig Silverman writes about CNN’s iReport…

The protests that erupted in Nigeria earlier this month over skyrocketing fuel prices initially received only a small amount of coverage from North American media, including CNN.

But CNN’s iReport team soon began seeing a steady stream of photos, videos and on the ground reports submitted by users in Nigeria. It became clear they couldn’t ignore the story.

“CNN wasn’t really covering that story at all until we started seeing an outpouring of contributions of video and photos and people writing into iReport over and over for days,” said Lila King, participation director for CNN Digital. “It made us say, ‘Gosh, you know we really need to be paying attention to this.’ ”

The result was increased coverage on CNN properties featuring the material submitted by a range of Nigerian citizens and freelancers.

This is iReport’s fifth anniversary, and a CNN spokesperson calls it “the most developed and active citizen journalism platform of any news organization worldwide.” It claims 1,002,428 registered iReporters, and 2.4 million unique users each month. King said iReport has had content submitted from every country on earth.

Free for All: 01/27/12

What’s on your mind?

Dylan Ratigan Profile…

The Miami Herald’s Glenn Garvin profiles Dylan Ratigan…

Certain that the financial collapse of 2008 would trigger major political and economic reforms, Ratigan left a successful show on the business network CNBC for MSNBC, which he thought would be a better forum for delving into politics. He was surprised — and ticked off — that little seemed to be happening.

“That was my naïveté,” Ratigan says. “What stunned me was that neither the media nor the political parties were willing to engage in debate on the corruption in our banking system which underlay the financial collapse. Since then, not only is there no debate on banking corruption, but there’s no debate on corruption in healthcare or in trade policy.

“The unifying factor in all those matters is that the funding of both our political parties comes mainly from the greedy bastards, the big corporations, who are buying our politicians.”

The focus of Ratigan’s show since then has been the nexus between big business and government, a dirty game in which corporations use government to leverage big profits, while leaving their losses to be covered by taxpayers. Not that taxpayers are wholly innocent, he quickly adds.

The Hazards of Live TV: #25,141

Gremlins in the FNC tape machinery again?

Geraldo Rivera Interview…

The Orange County Register’s Gary Lycan interviews Geraldo Rivera about his new LA radio show…

I always wanted to do radio,” Rivera said. “I am kind of a liberal Republican but I’m not always right. I hesitated for several reasons, one of which is that it is so labor intensive. As radio talk took hold, I saw it skew hard right. Everyone wanted to be Rush. But for him, there would never have been a Tea Party or a Fox News Channel.

“I am for free enterprise. I want people to be responsible for themselves as a family. The times when we had liberals like Nelson Rockefeller and Jacob Javits have all but evaporated. I think the party is reduced because of it.”

Assessing his WABC program, he said, “It’s hard to tell. Lots of sponsors have come around, the phone calls are always coming in. The ratings are delayed. We get some numbers next month. My sense is all the people who call me have said they ‘appreciate your coverage of the wars.’”

Rivera will do both shows live from KABC starting Monday, Jan. 30. He will later divide time between New York and LA. On Sunday, Jan. 29, he will meet everyone and start to “figure out where I am living.”

CNN’s Crowd Egging Debate Controversy…

When NBC had its crowd-noiseless debate on Monday, it drew criticism from some quarters for NBC’s decision to tell the crowd to refrain from outbursts. As tonight’s CNN debate drew closer some CNN staffers/talent were making note that their debate wouldn’t have this restriction. Okay, not having that restriction is one thing. Egging on the crowd deliberately is another thing entirely.

Keith Olbermann tweeted the following tonight…

You know what CNN guy w/his hands up is doing, right? He’s egging on the #FLdebate audience to clap – like a game show (link)

I wasn’t watching the debate as we’ve had too many and none having much to do with my state of California but when I saw that tweet I tuned in at the end and I saw a floor guy, probably the same floor guy, whipping up the crowd with his arms just as the debate ended. So that’s two instances of CNN egging on the debate crowd. How many more of those incidents were there?

Florida CNN Debate: Your reactions…

Post you reactions to the Florida GOP CNN debate and the coverage thereof here…

Andy Levy Profile…

Michael Elkin profiles Red Eye’s Andy Levy in Jewish Exponent…

An unapologetic libertarian — like host and friend Gutfeld — whose mischievous mantra is “I apologize for nothing,” this political science grad of Columbia University helps make it all politics as unusual on a program where blistering broadsides are interspersed with cracks on Gutfeld’s gnome-like height, weird webcam posts of pets in comical positions and conspiratorial conversations between guests.

It is, as Gutfeld once sniveled, “kind of like The View, but with bladder control.”

Gutfeld controls the tempo, but Levy holds him in check with his “pre-game” and “halftime reports,” and “postgame wrap.”

So, what’s the rap on Levy, whose esoteric bio includes time served in the miliary as well as war time in the jungles of Hollywood, and keyboard work for singer Dalton Grant?

He and the host, Levy says, live in a time warp: “We have the same warped sensibility,” Levy concedes of why he and Gutfeld can gut it out so well on TV. “We make a good team.”

Free for All: 01/26/12

What’s on your mind?

Free for All: 01/25/12

What’s on your mind?

Jennifer Granholm Interview…

Politico’s Patrick Gavin interviews Current TV’s Jennifer Granholm…

“I will be a progressive, and I will be on the left side of the spectrum,” Granholm said. And she will be, largely, supportive of what she sees coming out of the Obama administration.

“The show must be totally honest if it’s to work and, so, if there are things that the administration or others are doing that I disagree with, even though they may be Democrat, of course I want to be able to unearth that. But I don’t want to presume that I’m going to find a lot of that because I really do independently support the president and the direction he’s heading in.”

This all came together, thanks to a phone call from Current TV co-founder Al Gore.

“It was completely out of the blue,” said Granholm, who left office after she was term-limited out at the end of 2010. “It was not something that I was even thinking about for one moment, and he was very persuasive, especially since it was covering something near and dear to me and every political junkie’s heart, which is the 2012 election. I said, sure, I’ll do it.” (At the time, Granholm’s move to Current was considered a minor coup, since she was a contributor to NBC’s “Meet the Press.”)

Ed Schultz and Paul Begala to Participate in Democratic Retreat…

Roll Call’s John Stanton writes about an upcoming Democratic retreat and what’s going to happen. Ed Schultz and Paul Begala will be there…

Wednesday evening’s festivities are highlighted by an “American Voices Panel” that includes pundit Paul Begala and the leaders of several Democratic-leaning interest groups, while MSNBC host Ed Schultz will participate in a panel on Minority Whip Steny Hoyer’s (Md.) “Make it in America” plan.

I’m surprised both CNN and MSNBC will allow their people at these things.

Update: TVNewser’s Chris Ariens reports that MSNBC execs signed off on Schultz going there. I never thought otherwise. But it’s the second part of Ariens’ reporting that caught my eye…

Schultz will also conduct an on-site interview with Minority Leader Nancy Pelosi which will air on his show tomorrow night.

The storyline just changed. It’s no longer “Why does MSNBC allow Schultz to go to a Democratic poltical operation event retreat”. Nope. Now the storyline is “Does Ed Schultz still get that Pelosi interview if MSNBC doesn’t let Schultz go to this Democratic political operation event retreat?” Quid Pro Quo? Probably not. But it looks bad. Really bad. And apparently these kinds of cozy insidery appearances are A-OK with MSNBC brass. I guess it’s all about the access…

SOTU: Your reactions…

Post your reactions to tonight’s SOTU address and the coverage thereof here…

Free for All: 01/24/12

What’s on your mind?

George Lewis Retiring…

LA Observed’s Kevin Roderick writes that NBC News’ veteran reporter George Lewis is retiring…

George Lewis, the venerable NBC News correspondent in Los Angeles, is hanging up his microphone on January 31. What’s he doing today, on his last day in the field? Covering the Oscar nominations for the NBC Nightly News. Lewis has been with the network for 42 years. The network calls Lewis “one of NBC News’ most-honored correspondents — the winner of three Emmys, the George Foster Peabody and Edward R. Murrow awards.” He began with NBC as a war correspondent in Vietnam in 1970. When he passed 40 years, anchor Brian Williams gave Lewis a nice shout-out on the broadcast.

Liz Claman Interview…

The Jane Dough’s Amy Tennery interviews FBN’s Liz Claman…

TJD: Who are you most excited to interview?

LC: I have never been bored talking to Eric Schmidt of Google. I love it because other CEOs are so jealous of him. He is so smart and has such interesting ideas.

TJD: What kind of behind-the-scenes stuff goes on at Davos that you think people would never expect?

LC: It’s hilarious to see everyone star-struck. Last year, the chef of Red Rooster, Marcus Samuelson, was there. CEOs of major global banks were stumbling over each other to get to him to say hello.

And everyone has the same complaint: Their lodging.

TJD: Really?

LC: “Oh my hotel room is so small; it’s so far! Oh what a pain; oh they didn’t plow the road up to my hotel.” We pile on top of each other. [For] our crew, I think it’s two bedrooms and there are six of us. We don’t even care. We go and we figure out a way and it’s hilarious.

Press Releases: 01/24/12

CNN (1)

CNN Presents Live Coverage of President Obama’s State of the Union Address and GOP Response

Special Edition of AC 360 to Follow

Anderson Cooper and Wolf Blitzer will lead CNN’s coverage of the State of the Union beginning at 8 pm tonight along with John King and Candy Crowley. President Obama’s State of the Union Address will begin at 9:00 pm. The GOP response with Indiana Governor Mitch Daniels will follow.

Blitzer and King will anchor the special coverage live from Capitol Hill, where chief political analyst Gloria Borger and senior political analyst David Gergen will provide analysis immediately following the address. In addition, senior congressional correspondent Dana Bash will report live from inside the Capitol surrounding the address while chief White House correspondent Jessica Yellin provides the latest reports and insights of the president’s remarks from the White House. Political contributors participating in tonight’s special coverage include Paul Begala, Ari Fleisher and Roland Martin.

Deirdre Bolton Profile…

Chrissa Shoemaker profiles Bloomberg’s Deirdre Bolton on PhillyBurbs.com…

“There’s not really a more interesting time to be in business news,” Bolton said. “More and more people are more knowledgeable about their own finances, their government’s finances, the global credit crisis. Stories about the economy are on the front page of every newspaper. My job now is more putting those details in context for people. There’s so much information out there that the value-added we try to provide for people is explaining what’s going on in very clear terms.”

Anatomy of a Fiasco…

Philip Taylor blogs about a big bruhaha involving Suze Orman, a new pre-paid debit card she’s hawking, some ill-advised Tweeting, and FBN’s Geri Willis…

I’ve heard through a source close to the matter that Gerri Willis has been repeatedly called and emailed with criticism from Suze Orman’s PR firm over the reports she’s done surrounding the issues with Orman’s new pre-paid credit card.

I’m no stranger to this approach as I was labeled the idiot and I’ve seen suspect comments on my original post. But all this denial without much backing makes me question, why not just go on a national platform and engage your critics?

If the card is really as great as Suze says it is, wouldn’t we all benefit from an explanation from her?

Press Releases: 01/23/12

CNN (1)

René Marsh Joins CNN Newsource as Correspondent

René Marsh will join CNN Newsource from WSVN in Miami, Florida, as a national correspondent serving more than 800 affiliates, it was announced today by Paul Crum, vice president of news operations, administration and affiliate services for CNN/U.S.

Marsh will cover breaking news and topical news stories for CNN’s affiliates. She will be based in Washington, D.C. and will report from locations throughout the U.S.

“René is a sharp and poised reporter with a solid background in covering a vast array of news stories, from investigative to major breaking events. She will be on the frontlines of national breaking news and with her insights and presence, she will be a differentiator for our affiliate news partners and their viewers,” Crum said.

South Carolina Primary Ratings: CNN…

CNN is noting its South Carolina Primary Ratings…

According to Nielsen time period data for South Carolina primary election night: Saturday, January 21

Highlights:

CNN tops MSNBC in primetime (8-11p) and during full coverage block (7-11p)
CNN has a +60% advantage over MSNBC in demo in primetime and +74% during full coverage block
CNN has its best election night performance so far this cycle
CNN increases from 2008 South Carolina GOP primary night in both total viewers and the demo

Free for All: 01/23/12

What’s on your mind?

What’s Hot/What’s Not: 01/22/12

What’s Hot:

South Caroline Primary – It dominated the week and into the weekend.

Italian Shipwreck – It seems odd to me that this got as much press as it did. There have been lots of ship disasters but maybe that tape recording where the Captain got reamed had something to do with it.

Newt Gingrich – I hate giving this guy any attention but he was topic 1 for most of the week.

What’s Not:

Nothing made the cut this week…