The Five Celebrates Two Years (And ICN One Of Its Bigger Misses)…

Today Greg Guttfeld took to Twitter with me in his sights. You can read the full blast here on Twitchy complete with said anonymous poster’s schadenfreude, but the gist of it concerns a post I wrote when The Five was first announced.

I was going to do a full mea culpa here and say, “Yes Greg, I got it wrong! I have no excuses.” After all…I did get it completely wrong. It’s been two years and The Five is still on the air. Not only is it still on the air…it’s absolutely flourishing. You can’t get more wrong than that.

Plus, as one who has made a career out of holding on to bulletin board material for years or dug up some obscure point I read somewhere just to throw it back in someone’s face when the time was right, I have to admire whoever held on to this post for this long. (I doubt it was Guttfeld. I would think once The Five took off the way it did he would have unloaded on me sooner than this if he had read it at the time I wrote it. I have a feeling someone recently dug it up and pointed it out to him and he ran with it. Nothing wrong with that though.) But whoever was the one, my hat’s off to you. You rock.

But then I read my post all the way through in context and compared it to what Guttfeld wrote and my view changed somewhat. Consider this Guttfeld quote.

“2 years ago @InsideCableNews said this on #thefive: “Nobody involved in this project should feel too secure about its future””

Now here’s the full sentence I wrote…

“Nobody involved in this project should feel too secure about its future when the press release announcing it spells out that it has a short shelf life

Context matters here. That announcement said that The Five would run through at least the summer. That’s anything but a full scale endorsement. FNC wasn’t sure exactly what it would have on its hands and it hedged. So based on that my point still stands up. I wouldn’t feel too secure knowing that my show has an announced possible end date. Would you?

Here’s another cherry picked sentence…

“[thefive] so oddball it sticks out like a sore thumb. I don’t think it will last.” —

Here’s the full sentence…

“It’s an oddball fit for that time period…so oddball it sticks out like a sore thumb. I don’t think it will last.”

Your World comes before it and Special Report comes after it. So, yeah compared to what bookends The Five, it’s still an oddball fit for that time period, albeit a very successful oddball fit. As to the second part regarding how long it would last…I already acknowledged I got that totally wrong. I seriously underestimated the shift that was taking place in cable news away from news and more towards POV opinion which is now far more entrenched than it was two years ago.

And then there’s this quote Guttfeld cited…

“FNC is apparently out of new ideas and unsure of a future course of action regarding 5pm.”

That too is still accurate. There was nothing original about The Five. The View had already been there. The Talk had been there. FNC itself had already been there with its online Strategy Room. Combine that with the short lease on life and you get the picture of a network that cobbled something together that wasn’t original but wouldn’t commit long term to it at the outset. And, again, context matters. While this sentence was at least quoted in full, unlike the above quotes, it is taken out of context with what comes after…

FNC is apparently out of new ideas and unsure of a future course of action regarding 5pm. Why else take the equivalent of The Strategy Room and put it on TV with a wider subject spectrum but only guarantee that it will run through the summer? FNC had months to prepare for the day it would be without Beck and this is the best it could come up with? The TV programming equivalent of a band-aid? Talk about a half hearted endorsement.

Beck’s show, whether you like it or not, was unique in cable news and all broadcast news. Nothing had appeared like it before or since. You can’t say the same thing about The Five.

So while I’ll readily admit I whiffed on The Five lasting (and succeeding) the way it has, the rest of the shots Guttfeld took at me, I can’t take too seriously since Guttfeld wasn’t serious about quoting me in context.

Update: Wow…apparently I made FNC’s TV too. That’s interesting. Kind of odd that an “obscure media blog” would merit this much attention from FNC. That segment had to have been signed off on by someone. If I’m that obscure and that irrelevant, why bother? That would qualify as punching down and in this business you don’t do that because it invariably elevates the punchee to some degree if for no other reason than it makes them more well known. But whatever…if people want to play their games who am I to stand in their way? It’s actually kind of an honor that this “gnat” merited swatting on TV…


11 Responses to “The Five Celebrates Two Years (And ICN One Of Its Bigger Misses)…”

  1. That’s FOX’s shtick and has been for years. They go around,boast about ratings and how mighty they are and everyone else is obscure and then go out of their way to publicly smack down those obscure bloggers. Kind of like how they claim MSNBC has no audience but go out of their way to talk about MSNBC.

  2. You were a gift to them, and they know it, even if someone had to remind them. This is paying homage to you. Congrats!

  3. Actually they don’t go out of their way to publicly smack down those obscure bloggers. That’s a myth. They do go after them but through far more subtle means usually involving cutting them off at the kneecaps behind the scenes. Examples of that abound and just about every single major blogger or site has fallen victim to that at one point or another.

  4. jackyboy Says:

    Let them have this one Spud, The Five still sucks.

  5. lonestar77 Says:

    I think you’re correct on the first point, Spud, but I think you whiffed on the other two. At any rate, I love your blog and admire the fact that you actually pretty much play it straight down the middle when it comes to cable news analysis.

    I think Gutfeld was just having fun and I don’t consider the fact that they mentioned you on TV (I didn’t watch the clip) as punching down. That show is 30% serious 70% fun. It’s not like O’Reilly going after bathtub boy.

    Finally, the best part of all this is that Gutfeld reads this blog. That dude is awesome. And, Dana prolly read today and she’s hawt. So, hello Greg & Dana.

  6. paminwi Says:

    I say take the attention – it probably brought new readers to your blog. Maybe some will stay! You know FOX folks will want to see what your response is today after your so called “smackdown”!

    I think your analysis on this issue was good!

    I watch “The Five” when I’m doing food prep for dinner – because you can cut your vegetables, mix your sauces, marinade your meat and still get the gist of the show!

  7. Still Spud, It doesn’t hurt to get a shout out on the #2 rated cable news program from Gutfeld, so there’s that 😉

  8. I wonder which of our folks sent that to Gutfeld, since it’s highly unlikely that he came across it on his own. Early money is on Johnny Dollar. 😉

  9. ^ I’ll take that bet. 😉

  10. ICN is most definitely unvarnished now. Cool!

  11. […] brought up this subject. He did it three years ago on The Five’s second anniversary. And I responded to that. Short version: No excuses. I got it […]

Leave a Reply

Please log in using one of these methods to post your comment: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: