The Company Line?

Variety’s Brian Lowry calls out FNC’s Howard Kurtz for backtracking on covering Gabriel Sherman’s Roger Ailes book on his Sunday show. Normally I do not give much credence to Lowry’s FNC pieces because they are almost always slanted or otherwise negative towards FNC. But in this case, if Kurtz did say he was going to cover it only to not cover it, as Lowry writes, then Kurtz must account for why the change of heart…

For in-house media critics to have any credibility, they have to be willing to at least occasionally explore the shortcomings of their employers. And given all the coverage regarding Ailes’ concern regarding the book and his alleged campaign against the author, Kurtz looked caught between the proverbial rock and hard place — so much so that ignoring the book would have been preferable to creating the appearance of acting as Ailes’ surrogate.

Nevertheless, to promise coverage — as Kurtz did on air at the close of last week’s program — and then renege creates an impression of Kurtz as Ailes’ lap dog. And it’s not like there weren’t ways to approach Sherman’s biography in a skeptical manner, especially after New York Times critic Janet Maslin panned the book, providing some cover from one of the bastions of liberal media Fox News so regularly derides.

Either way, Kurtz appears seriously compromised, and looked even worse Sunday compared to CNN’s Brian Stelter, who gave his guests considerable latitude to second guess the volume of coverage his network devoted to Justin Bieber’s arrest.

To that last sentence I say….OUCH!

4 Responses to “The Company Line?”

  1. I agree. Kurtz has some splaining to do.

  2. ^^If he had discussed the Ailes bio this week I expect he would have had David Zurawik and Janet Maslin on to trash the book. This would have provoked even more discussion about how Media Buzz is one sided. I figure Ailes probably thought why give more air to the discussion after it had died down and killed the segment. It’s a bit embarrassing for Howie but it won’t be the last time he gets his wrist slapped for not towing the line.

    Stelter wasn’t great on this weeks show (sloppy questioning where guests didn’t know who was supposed to speak) but the subject matter and guests were excellent.

    Media Buzz was, aside from Anna Marie Cox, mostly just grating; particularly the segment on Beck.

  3. Whet defines grating depends on what you like in cheese.

  4. […] fashion that makes him so desirable to the suits at CNN. Inside Cable News has said they “don’t give much credence to Lowry’s FNC pieces because they are almost always slanted or otherwise negative towards […]

Leave a Reply

Please log in using one of these methods to post your comment:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: